Forum Offers Window Into A Brilliant Mind

October 21st, 2006 · 4 Comments · Local, Main

[Photo of Ahkil Reed Amar with Salisbury Forum President Franck A. de Chambeau courtesy of my Fujifilm S 5200 digital camera]

Last night I went to the Salisbury Forum’s first offering of the season. The subject — the history of the Constitution and the balance of powers — didn’t seem like the kind of lively lecture that would bring a couple hundred people into the Salisbury School chapel, perched high on a wind-swept hilltop on this ugly and blustery night.

Here’s the short version of my take on the event. We got a window into the mind of a brilliant man — Yale Law School Prof. Ahkil Reed Amar — who could very well wind up with a seat on the highest court in the land.

You heard it here: If you were at the forum last night, in just a few years you can say you saw Amar speak (and perhaps got a signed copy of his book) before the general public knew who he was when President Hillary Clinton nominated the former clerk for Justice Stephen Breyer to the Supreme Court. And, of course, you can say you learned a lot from listening to his lecture as well.

I exaggerate but only slightly. This fellow has all the best attributes I can think of in an educator and a possible justice: first-rate scholarship; the ability to explain his subject matter in a lively and accessible way; and — best of all — an unpredictable set of views that still seem bound together by a discernible mainstream philosophy. And he is a registered Democrat, so watch out, Antonin Scalia!

Here’s a sampling of what I learned. Amar began by saying that most people associate the phrase “Balance of Powers” with the three branches of government. But there is also a balance of power within the branches themselves: the judicial branch has both judges and juries; the legislatures are typically bicameral; and the executive branch has the power to convene grand juries that sometimes go against the executive’s wishes.

And the man offered insight into what accounts for the extraordinary degree of freedom we have as Americans. When he asked the audience what keeps us free, the responses were fairly typical: universal suffrage, a free press; lawyers (that response got a chuckle from everyone!).

No, Amar said. When the nation was founded, entire classes of people could not vote. As for a free press, under the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798, anyone “opposing or resisting any law of the United States, or any act of the President of the United States” could be imprisoned for up to two years. It was illegal to “write, print, utter, or publish” anything critical of the president or Congress. It was also a crime to criticize slavery in many parts of the South.

“People were thrown in jail for basically saying what Howard Dean is saying every day,” Amar quipped.

We remained free, Amar said, in much the same way Switzerland has. They have mountains; we have oceans (which he called “moats”), as do the Brits — another example he cited of a mostly free society. Is it our military that keeps us free? Yes and no, he said. Before World War II, the U.S. never had a large standing army during peacetime.

Asked which president he thought had most abused executive power, Amar forgivingly pointed to his hero, Abraham Lincoln, who suspended habeus corpus, among other things, Woodrow Wilson (I forget what he did) and Franklin Roosevelt, who set up internment camps for Japanese Americans and tried to pack the Supreme Court. He said he was willing to cut Lincoln and Roosevelt some slack because of the grave situations they faced. As for President Bush, Amar offered him no slack because — agree or disagree with the war in Iraq — it was “a war of choice.”

But the most interesting moment was when Amar was asked about whether he viewed the Constitution as a fixed proclamation or, as Al Gore has suggested, “a fluid document” subject to differing interpretations depending on the prevailing social climate. Amar burst forth (he did a lot of bursting forth last night) with a strong view that fluidity cuts both ways.

“The one reason I get a little nervous about a living document is what if we evolve away from equality?” he asked rhetorically. “You risk moving away from the very freedoms people fought and died for.” The living, breathing aspect of the Constitution is our ability to amend it, as we did with the 13th Amendment that ended slavery, he said.

I don’t know if Amar has written and said controversial things while a professor at Yale Law, as Judge Robert Bork did, so it’s not known if he would be “Borked” if nominated to sit on the high court. But I can tell you one thing. I would love to see him field questions from Orrin Hatch and Ted Kennedy during confirmation hearings. I might even call in sick to watch C-SPAN all day.

Tags:

4 responses so far ↓

1 jake // Oct 21, 2006 at 12:30 pm

What war isn’t a war of choice?

That pretty much tells you where this guy is coming from.
2 Terry // Oct 21, 2006 at 4:17 pm

He also said it would be “terrible if we lost the war in Iraq,” a comment which elicited a couple of barely audible gasps from the mostly Democratic audience.

As for his use of the phrase “war of choice,” I have also heard righties like Pat Buchanan use those very words to describe this war, so I’m not sure that means Amar is with the Cindy Sheehan crowd.
3 Amy // Oct 21, 2006 at 9:10 pm

If your prediction is right, and Hillary Clinton is elected President, I will be leaving the country. Incidentally, has anyone else seen the polls done that if she inlcudes her maiden name (Hillary Rodham Clinton) that she would win the election in 2008, but if she just went by Hillary Clinton, she would likely lose?
4 Terry // Oct 21, 2006 at 9:27 pm

Amy,

I trust you will do a better job of fulfilling your promise than Alec Baldwin, who vowed just such a move if GWB were re-elected in 2004.

Needless to say, Alec basically said “never mind” about his pledge to move to Canada, where the federal government would have taken 60% of his income right off the top. That’s too bad, Amy, because we need more people like you and fewer Alec Baldwins.

ARKANSAS TRAVELERS BASEBALL SCHEDULE 2006

HILTON HOTEL KUALA LUMPUR CENTRAL

AIRFARE LOWEST PRICE

TRAVELING WILBURYS TABS

CENTRAL LONDON HOTELS 4 STAR

OMNICEF CEFDINIR CAPSULES

CARDURA SIDE EFFECTS SYMPTOMS

CARNIVAL CRUISE LINE TYCOON DOWNLOADS GAMES

GULF AIR CHEAP TICKET

DISCOUNT CRUISES CARNIVAL CONQUEST

ARTHRITIS DRUGS CELEBREX

LOTENSIN BENAZEPRIL SIDE EFFECTS

BINTAN RESORT FERRY TIMETABLE

ISOPTIN MEDICINE SIDE EFFECTS

TRAVELING AGENCY NURSES

DOUBLETREE HOTEL AUSTIN TEXAS UNIVERSITY

DURANGO COLORADO SKI RESORTS

SISTERHOOD OF THE TRAVELLING PANTS SOUNDTRACK LIST

ATLANTIS RESORT AND CASINO LAS VEGAS

FOUR SEASONS HOTEL NEW YORK RESTAURANT

ZYLOPRIM MANUFACTURER

CHEAP AIR TICKETS INTERNATIONAL INDIA

LAST MINUTE AIR TICKETS SALE

WATERPARKS SANDUSKY OHIO KALAHARI RESORT

DOUBLETREE HOTELS ORLANDO

BEST CARIBBEAN ALL INCLUSIVE RESORTS FOR FAMILIES

RECYCLER CLASSIFIEDS

ALL HABBO HOTEL CHEATS AND CODES WEBSITES

FLUCONAZOLE DIFLUCAN USED

MARRIOTT HOTEL NEW YORK CITY LEXINGTON

LONDON HOTEL HILTON OLYMPIA

WHAT IS DICLOFENAC POTASSIUM

LIST OF TRAVELLING AGENTS IN MALAYSIA

FOODS CONTAINING ENZYME COQ10

ALL INCLUSIVE RESORT ATLANTIS IN BAHAMAS

QANTAS ROUND THE WORLD AIR TICKETS

ALBUTEROL INHALER SIDE EFFECTS IN INFANTS

PRINCESS ALASKA CRUISE REVIEWS

CAMP INN TRAVEL TRAILERS OF WISCONSIN

HARBORSIDE RESORT ATLANTIS RENTAL

RELAFEN 500MG DRUG

BLUES TRAVELER FOUR RUN AROUND

LAST MINUTE AIRFARES DISCOUNTS

VOLTAREN EYE DROPS PATIENTS

DOSAGE ERYTHROMYCIN ACNE

CHILD TRAVELING ALONE

HOTELS HILTON HEAD ISLAND SOUTH CAROLINA

TOM CRUISE WEDDING DATES

NICOLE KIDMAN AND TOM CRUISE PICTURES

ALPROSTADIL INJECTION VIDEO

THE GRAND PRINCESS CRUISE

CARNIVAL CRUISE LINES GALVESTON PORT

ATLANTIS RESORT NASSAU BAHAMAS

RENAISSANCE HOLLYWOOD HOTEL

TRAVELING WILBURYS VIDEO

WHERE CAN I BUY AMERICAN EXPRESS TRAVELERS CHECKS

ENLARGED PROSTATE AVODART

ACID REFLUX MEDICATION PROTONIX

CHECK AIRLINE FLIGHTS IN ROUTE

DSWD APPLICATION FOR MINORS TRAVELLING ABROAD

SIGNS OF OVERDOSE LAMICTAL

ACTOS PLUS BUY

COSTA CRUISE LINES EMPLOYMENT

UNITED AIRLINE FLIGHTS FLY

ALLEGRA FILOMENO

HOTEL SHERATON SURABAYA INDONESIA

MARRIOTT HOTEL LONDON HEATHROW

WEDDING TOM CRUISE KATIE HOLMES

AVAILABLE JOBS ON DISNEY CRUISE SHIPS

CELEBRITY CRUISES REPOSITIONING

EXTENDED STAY HOTEL SUITES SAN ANTONIO TEXAS

PLAVIX NEWS REPORT

CHEAP FLIGHTS TO NEW YORK FROM MANCHESTER AIRPORT

WAYS TO QUIT SMOKING ZYBAN

EXELON PATCH SIDE EFFECTS

ATLANTIS CASINO RESORT AND SPA IN RENO NV

BINTAN ANGSANA RESORTS

NORWEGIAN CRUISES LINES REVIEWS

TRICOR 145 MG FENOFIBRATE

BEVERLY HILTON HOTELS