Easy Perfect Pie Crust
Many cooks who can flambe, french and butterfly with ease find pie crusts to be completely unmanageable. I can’t flambe, french, butterfly or even make an acceptable omelette, but I think I’ve found a way to make a reliable and delicious crust.
The recipe I use isn’t actually for pie crust (I know, it’s cheating, but sometimes cheating works). It comes from the Williams Sonoma “Mexican” cookbook and is actually a dough for empanadas. With the addition of a bit of sugar, it’s easy to work and tastes flakey, light and buttery.
Before the instructions: a tip that I probably learned from Martha Stewart. After you make a few pie crusts, you begin to understand what a proper crust is supposed to feel like. You can tell if it’s too dry (which means it will break while you’re rolling it) or too moist (which means it will stick to the rolling pin, and then break while you’re rolling it).
You know you have the perfect combination of fats and flour when the dough peels easily off the sides of your mixing bowl without crumbling in your hands.
It should feel like it’s going to stick just until the moment that it peels away and forms a nice fat little ball of dough. If it sticks to the bowl and you have to scrape it off the sides, add a teaspoon or so of flour and mix it in fast and with a few decisive movements of your hand; overworked pie dough has the texture of plywood. If it’s too crumbly and doesn’t want to make a nice ball, add a teaspoon of water and mix it in fast.
Sometimes these little additions are necessary because of variables such as the humidity in the air or the amount of fat in your butter. It’s not a big deal so don’t get nervous. Just don’t add a LOT of water or a lot of flour to correct your problem. If you need to add more than a teaspoon or two, something is probably deeply wrong and you should scrap your dough and start over.
I know, I promised this would be easy, and it will be.
The last thing to know before you begin (this is the Martha Stewart part): once the dough peels nicely off the sides of the bowl, it should form a nice smooth ball that feels as smooth and pliant as a baby’s bottom (a nice clean one, with a little dusting of powder on it).
Here goes:
Bring 1 cup butter (as with most pastries, butter with a high fat content brings the best results) and 6 ounces of cream cheese to room temperature. Cream them together in a big bowl. You’ll be tempted to use your food processor but don’t do it; the ingredients are so sticky that they’ll just clump up on your blades. Use your hands. It’ll be messy but not horrible. And if once you add the flour, you’ll see: the fats should peel right off your fingers.
Stir in 2 cups all-purpose flour and a pinch of sea salt. Work the dough with your hands until it holds together and forms a nice smooth ball — and then stop working it. Your crust will get hard if you work it too long and hard.
Wrap it in plastic wrap and crush it into a flat round disc. Refrigerate for 15 minutes.
This dough works well with all kinds of fillings but it also makes a perfect rustic apple tart: Take a bunch of apples, all different kinds (northern spy is considered the best pie apple, but I also mix in macouns, and anything else that looks fairly crisp and flavorful). Peel them, remove the seeds and cut them into thin slices. Mix with sugar (I go light on the sugar, but you can add 1/2 a cup or more for 10 apples if you like it sweet; or skip the sugar and just use a quarter cup of maple syrup instead), cinnamon, maybe a little candied ginger, walnuts, raisins.
Mix the ingredients together and let them sit for 10 minutes or so until their flavors meld.
Preheat the oven to 375.
Roll out your dough on a flat board or a clean counter. I don’t use flour when I roll out because it makes the dough harden up. Instead, I put a layer of plastic wrap over and under the dough as I roll.
Once again, remember what Martha Stewart said: you want to roll gently and firmly out from the center to the edge in a continuous motion. Don’t vigorously run the roller back and forth.
Put a sheet of parchment paper over a baking sheet. Lay your crust, which should be about 1/8 inch thick, out on the parchment. Don’t worry about trimming the edges so they’re perfect and round (you’ll see why in a minute).
Pile the apples into the center of the dough. Don’t worry if the pile is fairly high, but be sure you leave at least two inches of unencumbered crust around the edges.
Dot the top of the apples with about 2 tablespoons of butter, cut into small pieces.
Bring the edges of the crust up and around the apples, folding the corners in.
Beat one egg with a teaspoon or so of water and brush the mixture onto the outside of your pie crust.
This all bakes up nicely in my oven in about 15 minutes, but I have a hot fast oven. Keep an eye on your crust and when it’s golden brown, take it out. Serve it right away, or leave it for up to 24 hours.
Good luck! And let me know how this recipe worked for you.

